Why AI can never replace human therapists
Professor Michael Atar
- Published
- Opinion & Analysis

More people are turning to AI chatbots for emotional support and quasi-therapeutic guidance, but psychoanalytic psychotherapist Professor Michael Atar warns that while artificial intelligence may simulate empathy, meaningful therapeutic healing still depends on genuine human connection
A major new European survey has found that nearly half of young people now use AI chatbots to discuss intimate or personal matters, with many describing them as “confidants” or “life advisers”.
In many ways, this should not surprise us. For busy professionals especially, the attraction is obvious as many executives and entrepreneurs are already isolated by the pressures of leadership. Their lives are time-poor and mentally overloaded, and in that dynamic AI — which is instant, available around the clock, non-judgemental and, perhaps most importantly, emotionally uncomplicated — can feel like an appealing shortcut.
There are no waiting lists, no awkward silences, no fear of embarrassment and no need to make time in an already overcrowded diary. You can ask it difficult questions at midnight and receive an immediate response.
For some, that can feel therapeutic, presenting a new form of therapy without the traditional inconveniences.
But I think this growing reliance on AI for emotional support perhaps reflects a wider misunderstanding about what therapy actually is.
There is often a misconception that psychotherapy is primarily advice-giving or reassurance. It is understandable why, to those on the outside, it may seem like this, and if therapy were simply about hearing comforting or sensible words then artificial intelligence may well be capable of replacing much of the process.
The reality, though, is that therapy operates on levels far deeper than language alone.
As human beings, we are profoundly social by nature. From infancy onwards, our emotional wellbeing and development depend upon interaction with other people. We constantly respond to subtle emotional cues in tone, expression, pacing, silence and presence, often without consciously realising it.
This process is not simply ‘body language’, as it is sometimes reduced to. It is much deeper and more instinctive than that.
The psychotherapist and neuroscientist Dr Allan Schore, for example, has written extensively about emotional attunement and how human beings regulate one another through right-hemisphere communication occurring beneath conscious awareness. In simple terms, our nervous systems are constantly interacting with one another — we regulate each other emotionally.
A calm and emotionally present therapist therefore does much more than merely listen to words. Their presence itself becomes part of the therapeutic process. The patient gradually feels safe enough to explore anxieties, fears and vulnerabilities that may otherwise remain hidden or defended against.
Artificial intelligence can undoubtedly provide information. It can reflect language back to us in sophisticated and sometimes impressive ways. It can even simulate empathy, to a degree. But it cannot genuinely participate in human emotional reciprocity because it does not possess emotional experience itself. It cannot sit in the room with another human being, pick up on subtle shifts in emotion, sense tension or hesitation or respond instinctively to the emotional atmosphere that develops.
While modern professional life has become increasingly frictionless, with instant communication and information retrieval, emotional life does not work according to the same principles as productivity software.
Ironically, the very parts of therapy many people find difficult — the moments of silence, vulnerability, unpredictability and emotional discomfort — are often the parts that matter most. A therapist is not there simply to reassure us or validate every feeling we have. Therapy is an evolving relationship through which unconscious patterns gradually emerge over time, and that process requires another human mind.
It requires someone capable not only of hearing what we say but also noticing what we avoid saying, what we repeat, how we emotionally respond and how we relate to someone else in real time.
There are therefore risks in increasingly turning to AI as a form of emotional substitute.
Unlike a therapist, an AI chatbot cannot truly challenge us relationally, because meaningful therapy cannot be reduced to information exchange. The interaction can, therefore, risk becoming a kind of echo chamber where the individual is, in effect, speaking to an endlessly accommodating version of themselves.
This is perhaps comparable to the growing tendency for people to self-diagnose medical conditions online. Access to information can certainly be helpful, but information alone is not the same thing as professional medical care. In the same way, AI may provide reflection or temporary reassurance, but that is not the same as psychotherapy.
Psychotherapy has long been treated as a serious scientific and medical discipline for precisely this reason. Many of the early pioneers of psychoanalysis and psychotherapy, including Freud and Winnicott, were medically trained doctors deeply interested in human development, attachment and emotional life.
Of course, AI may still have a constructive role within mental healthcare. It may help some people access information, reflect upon their feelings or take initial steps towards seeking support. Used ethically and carefully, it may become a valuable supplementary tool.
But we should be cautious about confusing emotional simulation with genuine human understanding.
Over thousands of years, we evolved as social creatures whose survival depended upon cooperation, communication, emotional bonds and community. Our ability to adapt, empathise, create relationships and regulate emotion has always depended heavily upon interaction with one another, and the AI revolution has not changed that core need.
Technology can support many aspects of our lives, but it cannot fully replicate those relational foundations. Regardless of how many advances in machine intelligence come along, our emotional and mental healing will remain, fundamentally, a human process.

Professor Michael Atar is a psychoanalytic psychotherapist with a background in medicine and over 25 years’ experience as a paediatric dentist. A father to a large family, he works with parents, carers, families, and children of all ages, offering a warm, collaborative and non-judgemental space. His work includes support for postnatal depression, PTSD, and developmental concerns such as feeding, sleep, and bonding difficulties. He also supports individuals and couples before, during and after pregnancy. Professor Atar is a member of UKCP, BACP, and GPsyC.
READ MORE: ‘The many lives of Professor Michael Atar‘. From paediatric dentistry to sepsis technology, psychotherapy and social innovation, Professor Michael Atar has built a career that refuses to stay in one lane. The European’s Dr Stephen Simpson meets the man whose work spans medicine, physics, mental health and community life.
Do you have news to share or expertise to contribute? The European welcomes insights from business leaders and sector specialists. Get in touch with our editorial team to find out more.
Main Image: Tima Miroshnichenko/Pexels
TOP STORIES
-
Meet the seven Anthropic founders worth $23bn each after record-breaking stock market debut -
World's robotics leaders to gather in Germany in race to put AI to work -
Britain's most expensive seaside resort dominates £2m property sales -
Beavers return to Loch Ness after 500 years -
Swiss data centre to heat homes using waste energy from AI servers -
Uzbekistan attracts $44.1bn in foreign investment and loans in nine months -
Serko raises revenue forecast as Booking.com business travel bookings surge -
Air India and Airbus unveil India's first corporate green aviation fuel scheme -
Best Western loyalty scheme to be scrapped in major hotel rewards shake-up -
First class delivery: China's postal service puts humanoid robots to work across eight cities -
AI set to transform university librarians' jobs as 95% predict surge in demand -
Washington Dulles unveils new concourse as $20bn airport expansion takes off -
The European Autumn 2026 edition – out now -
WATCH: Greenpeace drops giant David Attenborough boulder into North Sea – on site of £12bn windfarm -
Himalayan nations demand urgent action as UN warns of irreversible glacier losses -
6,000 march against ‘monstrous’ AI data centres as Scotland faces building boom -
Shop till Ai drop? AI agents set to buy for us as tech boss warns of retail revolution -
Specs appeal: Welsh Parliament bans smart glasses -
European motoring legends behind Mercedes, BMW and McLaren to enter Hall of Fame -
Putin 'plotting to break NATO without firing a shot', Latvian military analyst warns -
British AI chip startup hits £5bn valuation as government backs bid to challenge global tech giants -
World's biggest military airshow moves to ‘Britain’s Area 51’ after Iran war disruption at RAF Fairford -
Lisa Nandy threatens crackdown on entertainment industry after David Walliams allegations -
UK and European experts demand tougher AI laws as Australia considers criminal penalties after OpenAI breach -
BBC loses bid to throw out Trump's $10bn defamation lawsuit over doctored Panorama speech
Why AI can never replace human therapists
Professor Michael Atar
- Published
- Opinion & Analysis

TOP STORIES
-
Powerful men need to hear ‘no’ from people they can’t sack -
Universities risk losing students’ trust over failing AI rules -
007 reasons why James Bond should be played by a disabled actor -
Carrie Gracie's BBC pay battle exposes sexism's dirty secret -
The great AI shame game -
Businesses risk losing staff trust over poorly explained AI plans -
Monty Python filmmaker claims to have found the Garden of Eden -
The short and the short of it: children's fiction is shrinking -
Grandfathers can play vital role in preventing boys being brainwashed by the manosphere -
Landlord tax rises risk pushing rents higher -
Why Britain must put Black women at the heart of its public art -
Trumpism will survive the Democrats' midterm victory -
How Putin plans to break NATO without going to war -
The scuba diving project helping to protect Cornwall’s lobster population -
For Your Eyes Only. Why the new Bond needs a woman's perspective -
It's time to pull the plug on dangerous AI agents -
Sound of silence: Why AI could leave disabled musicians unheard -
Could the BBC survive without the licence fee? -
Visionaries in focus – how spectacles became symbols of political power -
The coach driver building a dating platform in his sixties -
If I were Chancellor, disabled people’s independence would be at the heart of the Budget -
Trump, Europe and the battle over who controls free speech -
Frozen bank accounts, NHS errors and food shortages. How AI could trigger a national crisis -
AI might kill us all, but not until it’s got what it wants -
UK government urged to ban personalised price rises based on shoppers’ online behaviour




















































