The uncomfortable question behind the attacks on Lord Simon Woolley
Daniella Maison
- Published
- Opinion & Analysis

Lord Simon Woolley was condemned for describing the treatment of his late friend Professor Jason Arday as a “public assassination”. But was he right? Writer and social justice commentator Daniella Maison asks whether Black people in positions of power are too often put in the firing line for mistakes and remarks that others survive unharmed
Three weeks ago, Lord Simon Woolley, the Principal of Cambridge University’s prestigious Homerton College, spoke publicly about his friend, the late Professor Jason Arday. Standing in Trafalgar Square before a crowd organisers said numbered more than 30,000, Woolley described how Arday had been the victim of a “lynching” and a “public assassination”. His colleague had been Professor of Sociology of Education at Cambridge until resigning from the university on 5 August following weeks of intense media scrutiny over allegations of plagiarism and questions about his academic record and achievements.
Just days later, Woolley told the crowd, he had consoled Arday over dinner. Woolley had been joined by Diane Abbott MP and photographer and activist Misan Harriman. The three had met Arday because, Woolley said, they knew he was struggling.
“We held him in our arms,” Woolley said. “We told him he was loved.”
He recalled Arday holding Abbott’s hands and saying: “I love you, but they’re hounding me to death, and I cannot see a way out.”
Arday, 41, was found dead at his home in Battersea, south London, on 14 August.
Woolley has led Homerton College since 2021. Before his appointment, he founded Operation Black Vote, created and led the Government’s Race Disparity Unit, served on the Equality and Human Rights Commission, advised successive governments on equality and representation, and was appointed to the House of Lords.
He is, then, a substantial establishment figure with a long record in public life, academia and government.
And yet, within a fortnight of his speech, some quarters of the media were questioning not only his judgement over Arday and the language he had used, but Woolley’s own credentials and fitness to remain in his post.
Woolley, much like Arday before him, is now facing scrutiny over whether he belongs in one of Britain’s most prestigious academic positions.

Diane Abbott MP, herself a Black figure in a position of authority, knows a thing or two about the personal cost of speaking bluntly about race. In 2023, she wrote to the Observer arguing that different minority groups experience prejudice in different ways, and that the racism historically directed at Black people has taken a distinct and particularly entrenched form. She pointed to slavery and racial segregation in the United States, including laws that forced Black people to sit at the back of buses, to explain the distinction she was trying to make.
Her letter was widely condemned, particularly for suggesting that Jewish, Irish and Traveller people experience prejudice rather than racism. Abbott, who apologised and withdrew the remarks, was later suspended for more than a year after Labour withdrew the whip.

None of this is to condone the use of inflammatory language that deepens division or risks fuelling prejudice. But if society – and the media – is prepared to condemn people such as Woolley and Abbott when they speak controversially about race and the treatment of others, then the same standards must be applied consistently across every political party and in every comparable case. Criticism and consequences cannot depend on who is speaking. It cannot be one rule for one person and another for someone else.
Consider, by comparison, the latitude afforded to Suella Braverman. As Home Secretary, she reportedly described the arrival of asylum seekers in small boats as an “invasion”, warned of a “hurricane” of mass migration and characterised pro-Palestinian demonstrations as “hate marches”.
Her language provoked fierce criticism, including from within her own party. Yet none of those remarks resulted in her suspension from the Conservative parliamentary party or a prolonged argument about whether she was entitled to remain an MP.
In academia, allegations of plagiarism and findings of academic negligence are hardly unknown. Yet they rarely attract anything approaching the national attention that surrounded Arday, or the subsequent scrutiny of Woolley.

Take the 2023 case of Cambridge historian William O’Reilly who, after a university investigation upheld a complaint that material from an undergraduate student’s essays had appeared in an article published under his name, reportedly threatened Cambridge student newspaper Varsity with legal action when it sought to publish the finding.
Or consider Nicola Morrison, then a senior lecturer in Cambridge’s Department of Land Economy, who apologised after an article published under her name reproduced passages from a student’s dissertation without attribution.
Neither case resulted in a public campaign questioning whether the academics concerned deserved their positions, nor were either subjected to weeks of sustained and highly personal media scrutiny.
Based on these cases, and many others like them, it is easy to see why so many believe that Black people in positions of power – already so poorly represented – are, in Woolley’s words, publicly “lynched” when they speak out or get something wrong.

It is right and proper that anyone, regardless of ethnicity or skin colour, should be investigated, reprimanded or removed if their conduct falls below the standard expected of them. It is equally right that the media should report those failings, provided the same standards are applied consistently.
But to claim that a Black individual was never fit to hold a position of authority in the first place, despite the appointment processes, interviews, experience and credentials that put them there, goes far beyond legitimate scrutiny of their conduct.
Woolley, Abbott, Arday and others should be judged on what they say and do, and held accountable where appropriate. The danger comes when criticism of a mistake, controversy or poor judgement becomes an argument that they never belonged in positions of power at all.
If Black people are welcomed into senior roles only for their right to occupy them to be questioned the moment they become controversial, then diversity at the top remains far more conditional than many institutions would care to admit.

Daniella Maison is an award-winning writer and social justice commentator, author of The N Word, a contributor to The Independent, and a columnist for The Voice and Black Wall St Media.
READ MORE: How Britain turned Jason Arday into a symbol – and lost sight of the man. Celebrated as a symbol of Black achievement, Jason Arday later became the focus of intense scrutiny before his death at just 41. Dr Stephen Whitehead argues that, whatever the legitimate questions surrounding his scholarship, the public reckoning lost sight of the human being at its centre.
Do you have news to share or expertise to contribute? The European welcomes insights from business leaders and sector specialists. Get in touch with our editorial team to find out more.
Main image: Lord Simon Woolley, Professor Jason Arday and Diane Abbott MP in a composite image accompanying Daniella Maison’s article on race, scrutiny and power at Cambridge. Credits: Woolley portrait by Roger Harris / UK Parliament, CC BY 3.0; Abbott photograph by PaulNUK, CC BY 2.0; Cambridge background by Lamkingming, CC BY-SA 4.0; Homerton College background by Franman247, CC BY-SA 3.0; Arday image supplied.
TOP STORIES
-
Meet the seven Anthropic founders worth $23bn each after record-breaking stock market debut -
World's robotics leaders to gather in Germany in race to put AI to work -
Britain's most expensive seaside resort dominates £2m property sales -
Beavers return to Loch Ness after 500 years -
Swiss data centre to heat homes using waste energy from AI servers -
Uzbekistan attracts $44.1bn in foreign investment and loans in nine months -
Serko raises revenue forecast as Booking.com business travel bookings surge -
Air India and Airbus unveil India's first corporate green aviation fuel scheme -
Best Western loyalty scheme to be scrapped in major hotel rewards shake-up -
First class delivery: China's postal service puts humanoid robots to work across eight cities -
AI set to transform university librarians' jobs as 95% predict surge in demand -
Washington Dulles unveils new concourse as $20bn airport expansion takes off -
The European Autumn 2026 edition – out now -
WATCH: Greenpeace drops giant David Attenborough boulder into North Sea – on site of £12bn windfarm -
Himalayan nations demand urgent action as UN warns of irreversible glacier losses -
6,000 march against ‘monstrous’ AI data centres as Scotland faces building boom -
Shop till Ai drop? AI agents set to buy for us as tech boss warns of retail revolution -
Specs appeal: Welsh Parliament bans smart glasses -
European motoring legends behind Mercedes, BMW and McLaren to enter Hall of Fame -
Putin 'plotting to break NATO without firing a shot', Latvian military analyst warns -
British AI chip startup hits £5bn valuation as government backs bid to challenge global tech giants -
World's biggest military airshow moves to ‘Britain’s Area 51’ after Iran war disruption at RAF Fairford -
Lisa Nandy threatens crackdown on entertainment industry after David Walliams allegations -
UK and European experts demand tougher AI laws as Australia considers criminal penalties after OpenAI breach -
BBC loses bid to throw out Trump's $10bn defamation lawsuit over doctored Panorama speech
The uncomfortable question behind the attacks on Lord Simon Woolley
Daniella Maison
- Published
- Opinion & Analysis

TOP STORIES
-
007 reasons why James Bond should be played by a disabled actor -
Carrie Gracie's BBC pay battle exposes sexism's dirty secret -
The great AI shame game -
Businesses risk losing staff trust over poorly explained AI plans -
Monty Python filmmaker claims to have found the Garden of Eden -
The short and the short of it: children's fiction is shrinking -
Grandfathers can play vital role in preventing boys being brainwashed by the manosphere -
Landlord tax rises risk pushing rents higher -
Why Britain must put Black women at the heart of its public art -
Trumpism will survive the Democrats' midterm victory -
How Putin plans to break NATO without going to war -
The scuba diving project helping to protect Cornwall’s lobster population -
For Your Eyes Only. Why the new Bond needs a woman's perspective -
It's time to pull the plug on dangerous AI agents -
Sound of silence: Why AI could leave disabled musicians unheard -
Could the BBC survive without the licence fee? -
Visionaries in focus – how spectacles became symbols of political power -
The coach driver building a dating platform in his sixties -
If I were Chancellor, disabled people’s independence would be at the heart of the Budget -
Trump, Europe and the battle over who controls free speech -
Frozen bank accounts, NHS errors and food shortages. How AI could trigger a national crisis -
AI might kill us all, but not until it’s got what it wants -
UK government urged to ban personalised price rises based on shoppers’ online behaviour -
UK urged to introduce new laws to protect businesses from data vendor lock-in -
Europe’s towns fight back against the billion-euro AI data centre boom




















































