Businesses risk losing staff trust over poorly explained AI plans

Companies are pouring trillions into artificial intelligence, yet only a quarter of US employees say their employers have clearly explained how it will affect their work. With job losses adding to uncertainty, business strategy expert Marcus Iles warns that leaders risk alienating their workforces unless they involve staff in defining what AI is for and how it should be used

In the United States midterms, voters across 10 states backed restrictions on data centres or rejected plans to build them. Reuters reported that 40 of 41 ballot measures went against development, citing tracking by Redbud Consulting. Electricity costs, tax breaks and the impact on local communities were at issue. When people are asked to bear the costs of a change without understanding what they stand to gain, resistance becomes more likely. I see the same thing inside organisations. Leave people to work out what a change means for them and they will come up with an explanation of their own, rarely a generous one.

The approach I use with leadership teams starts from a simple observation. For people to act together on a strategy, they must hold three things in common: Attention, Interpretation and Expectation. Attention is what we are looking at. Interpretation is what we think it means. Expectation is what we believe will happen next and what is now expected of us. 

Everyone is looking at AI. I find that the other two questions are much harder for leaders to answer. Will it make my work more interesting or replace it? What, specifically, am I now expected to do?

Gartner forecasts worldwide AI spending of US$2.7 trillion in 2026. What has not yet arrived, in most organisations, is a purpose. Yet when Gallup asked U.S. employees about their employers’ AI plans in May, only a quarter said their organisation had communicated a clear plan for bringing AI into their work. In McKinsey’s 2025 survey, 39 per cent of respondents reported an effect on earnings before interest and tax across their organisation. There are many reasons an investment may fail to pay off. My concern is what happens when a plan is vague and a reduction in headcount is the clearest signal staff get. Salesforce chief executive Marc Benioff, for example, said in 2025 that the company reduced its support workforce from 9,000 to about 5,000 after introducing AI agents.

Researchers from Stanford, the University of Virginia and Dartmouth studied two similar divisions of a law firm using the same AI drafting tool. One manager introduced it as a way to draft documents faster. Paralegals in that division described feeling like “just another cog in the machine”. The other manager asked which tasks people found tedious and what they wished they had time for. Paralegals there used the tool 58 per cent more and experimented with it 70 per cent more, taking it into legal research and asking to join strategy meetings. That second group also received training, mentoring and time to experiment. 

The lesson is not that a better story alone produces better results, but that a clear purpose, backed by practical support, can change how employees engage with technology. Same technology, same firm, different story.

Leaders risk losing staff trust if they leave people guessing what AI means for their jobs. Employers should involve staff in deciding what AI is for and give them time and support to try it. Credit: Kaboompics / Pexels


Morgan Stanley gave its financial advisers a clear purpose for an AI assistant: less time searching documents and more time with clients. Its advisers helped grade the system’s answers before deployment. OpenAI, which supplied the technology, reports in its Morgan Stanley case study that more than 98 per cent of adviser teams used the assistant. Separately, in Gallup’s U.S. workforce survey, 79 per cent of employees who strongly agreed that their manager actively supported their team’s AI use were frequent users, compared with 46 per cent of those who did not strongly agree.

Why tell a story? It gives people a way to interpret the same change. In one study of how people interpret the same narrative, two groups heard the same story after being given different background information. Patterns of brain activity were more similar among listeners who interpreted the story in the same way. An organisation can send the same all-staff email about AI to ten thousand people and end up with several different organisations, each telling itself a different story.

A strategic narrative should answer three questions. First comes cause. What is AI for here, beyond speed and savings? Nobody stays late for efficiency. Then comes character. Who are we in this story, and who must leaders become? Do they use AI openly, protect the time it saves and still show up in person for the conversations that matter? Finally, we have consequence. What will change for me, and what will we never automate? A clear, consistent and compelling answer to all three does what no licence can: it gives people a part to play.

None of this is a communications exercise. Shared understanding only helps if people can act on it. Leaders must first listen to the stories already circulating about AI. Then they should shape a narrative people can act on, share it openly enough to be challenged and check that their own behaviour fits it. They will need to return to it as circumstances change. I would judge progress by whether people can tell the story in their own words and act on it together. Usage figures such as logins can only tell you how much people used the tool.

AI makes it easier to build organisations full of productive individuals working alone. Leaders who ask people to give their working lives to an organisation owe them somewhere to belong and people to act with. Data centres can be voted down but meaning cannot be voted in, bought or generated. It has to be built, with the people expected to act on it.


Marcus Iles is a business strategy and organisational behaviour expert specialising in strategy activation, leadership alignment, organisational storytelling and people engagement. With 25 years’ experience spanning advertising, creative strategy, organisational storytelling and consultancy, Marcus – a former Chief Storytelling Officer at The Storytellers and an award-winning advertising creative and strategist – examines why strategies that appear clear at leadership level can fragment when they are interpreted and acted upon across an organisation.



READ MORE: Barclays offers a golden lesson in how not to handle a return-to-office mandate. Barclays’ public retreat over its return-to-office policy reveals how even well-intentioned management decisions can backfire when employees are told what to do without understanding why. Marcus Iles says that if leaders want lasting change rather than reluctant compliance, they must build a shared sense of purpose.

Do you have news to share or expertise to contribute? The European welcomes insights from business leaders and sector specialists. Get in touch with our editorial team to find out more.

Main Image: Theo Decker / Pexels

TOP STORIES

Businesses risk losing staff trust over poorly explained AI plans

TOP STORIES