Wall Street disconnected from reality on the ground

John E. Kaye
- Published
- News

With the U.S. economy facing its potentially deepest economic decline in nearly a century, Wall Street is pulling further and further ahead from Main Street.
Trillions of dollars of fiscal and monetary stimulus to dampen the impact of the coronavirus pandemic on the U.S. economy and financial markets have sent stocks soaring off their lows, while the worst of the fallout on growth and employment has yet to be felt.
The following graphics illustrate the disconnect that has developed between the stock market and the reeling U.S. economy.
The staggering 20.5 million jobs lost in April put the U.S. unemployment rate at 14.7.
The S&P 500 tumbled more than 2% on Tuesday as investors weighed the risk of a second wave of infections against hopes for a reopening of the economy led by easing stay-at-home restrictions. Still, the benchmark has recovered around 30% since hitting March lows, even as wages decline and personal expenditures flatline.
Wall Street has also pulled far ahead of analysts’ forecasts for S&P 500 profits.
Global stocks tell the same story, with the MSCI World index recovering strongly even as global purchasing managers’ indexes decline.
The rebound on U.S. stocks has occurred even as economic indicators come in below economists’ expectations.
Dour economic news in recent weeks has been repeatedly shrugged off by investors, helping Wall Street recover from deep losses that in February ended an 11-year bull market. However, even after its rebound since March 23, the S&P 500 remains down 15% from its record high. A report from the National Federation of Independent Business on Tuesday showed small business sentiment slid in April to its lowest level since March 2013.
Small businesses are being hit disproportionately hard by prolonged shutdown, and the following graphic shows that while the survey respondents’ forward view of the economy improved, sales expectations tumbled.
A nearly 8% jump in average hourly earnings in Friday’s employment data suggests that the millions of jobs recently lost were mostly low-paying. In a potential silver lining, the data also indicated the vast majority of recent job losses were temporary rather than permanent.
“With 72% of jobs lost being reflected as temporary layoffs, workers should be able to be more seamlessly rehired as the economy reopens. But the longer this pandemic goes on, the more likely that what was temporary becomes permanent,” BofA Global Research analysts warned in a research note.
Recent data also shows the prime-age workforce is shrinking because of the pandemic, with women taking the biggest hit.
While many investors are optimistic about the timeline for a U.S. economic recovery, others remain more cautious about how quickly the economy will return to normal, and about whether the worst is over on Wall Street.
The recent disconnection between economic data and the direction of the stock market reflects broad uncertainty about short-term effects of the coronavirus-related lockdown and investors’ willingness to bet the economy will begin to bounce back as quarantines are lifted in stages across the country.
“My big worry for the market is we have a potential weak spot coming for the market in late May or mid-June because there is going to be this anxiousness that everything should pick up right away,” said JJ Kinahan, chief market strategist at TD Ameritrade in Chicago. “Right now, we are trading a lot on optimism, let’s be honest. Optimism meeting reality is what is going to happen there.”
Reported by Noel Randewich
Sourced Reuters
For more Banking & Finance and Daily news follow The European Magazine
Sign up to The European Newsletter
RECENT ARTICLES
-
Off the blocks: LEGO and Formula 1 reunite for documentary on viral Miami Grand Prix stunt
-
Mergers and partnerships drive Africa’s mining boom – but experts warn on long-term resilience
-
New AI breakthrough promises to end ‘drift’ that costs the world trillions
-
Europe tightens grip on strategic space data as dependence on U.S tech comes under scrutiny
-
Trinity Business School study warns conspiracy theories are fueling real-world protest and sabotage
-
GITEX GLOBAL 2025 to spotlight AI’s expanding role in future-critical sectors
-
UK organisations show rising net zero ambition despite financial pressures, new survey finds
-
HumanX to establish permanent European base with 2026 Amsterdam AI summit
-
Gulf ESG efforts fail to link profit with sustainability, study shows
-
Glastonbury and Coachella set the stage for $400bn music tourism growth
-
Geopolitical volatility enters global top ten business risks for first time, new survey finds
-
Redress and UN network call for fashion industry to meet sustainability goals
-
Dar Global unveils $1bn Trump Plaza Jeddah in second Saudi venture with Trump Organization
-
Investors eye UAE as Belt and Road real estate gateway for Asia
-
Mitsubishi Estate’s £800m South Bank scheme to deliver 4,000 jobs
-
Watch: driverless electric lorry makes history with world’s first border crossing
-
Bologna sets pace in Europe’s tech race with record investor–founder meetings
-
Family-owned firms resist board diversity gains despite gender quotas, study finds
-
UK start-up founders defy stereotypes with corporate roots and regional spread
-
London Law Expo 2025 to tackle leadership, AI and integrity in the legal sector
-
Sustainability skills surge in European boardrooms, EY finds
-
UK and U.S unveil landmark tech pact with £250bn investment surge
-
International Cyber Expo to return to London with global focus on digital security
-
Cybersecurity talent crunch drives double-digit pay rises as UK firms count cost of breaches
-
Trinity Business School strengthens standing in global MBA rankings